Wednesday, November 20, 2013

TBR Challenge Fail!

My attempt to meet this month's theme of an inescapably hyped book met with failure as I discovered, yet again, that even well-written and well-regarded small-town contemporaries rarely work for me. (I won't name the hyped book in question because I'm absolutely convinced it's a good book that just slammed into a severe case of book-reader mismatch with me. I think I've finally learned to stop even attempting this subgenre.) I then tried a few other books from the TBR pile that didn't meet the theme and finally settled on one that I'm enjoying, More Than a Governess by Sarah Mallory, but due to a packed schedule I haven't had time to finish it yet.

I did, however, come up with an idea for a contemporary romance! Girl grows up in small town, then moves to a big city for college--probably Philadelphia or Seattle, in the interests of Writing What I Know--and sticks around after graduation. Her career is off to a good start, in a field that satisfies her wallet, mind, and soul. She doesn't give much thought to her high school sweetheart until he contacts her on Facebook--he's going to be in Philly/Seattle soon. In the serious version of the story, his mom is sick and needs treatment at one of the world-class medical centers these major cities have to offer. In the lighter version, he's there for a conference or something. Either way, he wants to see her. She's curious enough to agree to meet, and turns out the chemistry is still there. She introduces him to the wonders the big city has to offer--food! culture! diversity! big time sports! freedom from busybodies! plenty of community if you know how to find it! He's tempted to ask her to come back to the small town with him, but he ultimately realizes she's made the right choice for her, and that he can and will find a way to make his career work in the city so they can be together. With, you know, more plot and conflict, but you get the picture.

I know, it'd probably never sell, and my writer's heart is with historical and historical fantasy anyway. But if anyone knows of a book that follows this pattern, please please tell me what it is so I can read it right away.

4 comments:

  1. I like this idea, and I know I've seen others asking for books like this, because of the numerous small-town-good-big-city-bad books out right now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe they'll catch on. I can't be the only city lover who wishes for a nice Seattle/San Francisco/Boston/New York/Philadelphia/etc. romance.

      Delete
  2. I would read this! So sick of the glorification of small towns. Most North American's (I live in Canada) live in a City/suburb/urban area. Let's have some city love beyond Chick Lit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's funny, I can enjoy small towns or villages in historicals or fantasy novels, or sometimes set in a different part of the world. But with American small towns, there's a certain political baggage I can't help being acutely aware of. Also, as someone who grew up in a small town and left, I feel like those books are telling me I've made the wrong choices.

      Delete